Forget what you know about delis.
The Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli in West Allis is no ordinary deli. Here, the humble PB&J is elevated to an art form, and you’re invited to enjoy the masterpiece.
Let’s dive into what makes this place a must-visit for families.
What’s the Scoop?
The Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli stands as Wisconsin’s only destination dedicated solely to celebrating the iconic PB&J Sandwich.
Located in the Six Points neighborhood of West Allis, this charming eatery takes the simple pleasure of peanut butter and jelly to a whole new level with classic and gourmet twists that will have both kids and adults coming back for more.
What To Try?
The deli offers an imaginative and extensive menu that has something for everyone.
With five house-made nut butters and dozens of jellies on the menu, the odds are good that you’ll find something just right for you.
Some of their most popular options are “Strawberry Lovers”, with crunchy, honey roasted peanut butter with strawberry jam and fresh sliced strawberries, and “The King”, a grilled delight of peanut butter, sliced bananas, and honey, with an option to add bacon.
For picky eaters, try the Build Your Own PBJ, where you can customize your sandwich with choices of bread, nut butter, and jam or jelly.
Add an extra layer of deliciousness to your sandwich with a wide range of toppings, including bacon, ham, mallow creme, marshmallows, Nutella, jalapeños, chocolate sauce, honey, caramel sauce, pickles, and sliced fruit like strawberries, apples, and bananas, among other tasty options like Sriracha sauce and cream cheese.
And don’t worry, they’re happy to let you sample to your heart’s desire until you find something you love.
For the adventurous foodies, there’s the Grilled Cheese and Jelly with your choice of cheese and jam or jelly, melted between your bread choice. (Try it with raspberry jalapeño jelly!)
Don’t miss out on trying their honey roasted peanut butter—affectionately dubbed “literal crack butter” by fans—or exploring their wide range of jelly flavors, from gooseberry and apricot.
Plus, they offer old school ice cream floats featuring their signature PBJ Deli Soda Pops, locally roasted coffee, and milkshakes.
Freshness on the Menu
One of the first things you’ll love about the PBJ Deli is their commitment to freshness and local sourcing.
The peanut butter is ground daily right in their shop, and the jams and jellies come from local jelly farms. The bread comes straight from nearby bakeries.
And if you want to take the goodness home, their fresh nut butter, jams, and jellies available for purchase.
A Nostalgic Nook
The deli’s decor is a trip down memory lane, adorned with nostalgic lunchboxes and old-school pictures.
It’s cozy, making it a perfect spot for families to enjoy a meal together.
Plus, it’s not just about eating; it’s an experience. Engage with the friendly staff, sample different peanut butters and jellies to your heart’s content, and maybe even leave with a new favorite lunchbox.
Kid-Friendly Through and Through
Extremely kid-friendly—that’s the consensus among parents. The staff go out of their way to accommodate little ones, even those with peanut allergies, by offering great PB alternatives.
The environment is clean, welcoming, and just the right setting for a family meal.
Practical Tips
- Location: Find your way to the Six Points neighborhood of West Allis to uncover this gem.
- Parking: Look around the neighborhood for street parking; it’s usually not too tricky to find a spot.
- Menu Picks: Can’t decide? The grilled cheese & jelly is a crowd-pleaser, and don’t shy away from sampling to find your perfect match.
- Sharing is Caring: With portions described as filling, consider splitting a sandwich with a friend or sibling to taste more flavors.
- Space Mural: Don’t miss the Space Mural on the side of the building!
The Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli is a celebration of a beloved classic, reinvented with a dash of creativity and a whole lot of love.
Whether you’re a local or just visiting, stopping by with your family promises a deliciously fun experience.
Happy eating!
More Kid-Friendly Restaurants
25 Kid-Friendly Restaurants Around Milwaukee
Calie Herbst, Editor-in-Chief of Milwaukee With Kids, has spent over a decade combining her experiences as a parent of three to create a hub for Milwaukee’s family adventures.
Her decade-long teaching career in Milwaukee Public Schools and academic background, including a Master’s in Teaching from Marquette University and dual B.A.s in Sociology and Spanish from the University of Wisconsin – Madison, fuel her passion for inclusive and engaging family content.
Calie is also a recognized voice in local media, contributing to WISN Channel 12 News, WTMJ Wisconsin Morning News, Fox 6’s Real Milwaukee, and B93.3.
Discover more about Calie’s journey and editorial approach on her About Page and Editorial Policy Page.